
The internet loves a good meme. Whether it’s a cat in a cardboard box or a clever one-liner about Monday mornings, memes have become our go-to way to laugh, relate, and sometimes even cry. But in an age where artificial intelligence can paint portraits, write essays, and compose music—can it also make us laugh?
We decided to put that to the test.
In a blind meme test involving real humans and AI-generated memes, the results were more surprising than you might think. If you’ve ever wanted to create your own meme in minutes, you might be wondering if AI can actually do the heavy lifting for you—and still bring the LOLs. The answer? It’s complicated.
Let’s break down what we discovered.
Setting the Stage: The Meme Showdown
To see whether AI can truly match human humor, we conducted a blind test with 500 internet users across different age groups and backgrounds. Each participant was shown 20 memes—a mix of 10 human-created and 10 AI-generated memes—without knowing which was which.
Participants were asked to rate each meme based on:
- Humor (Did it make you laugh?)
- Relatability (Did it hit close to home?)
- Originality (Was it fresh or cliché?)
- Overall impact (Would you share it?)
The memes covered a mix of topics: workplace humor, dating life, pop culture, and those infamous “adulting” struggles.
The Shocking Results: Who Really Won?
Here’s where it gets interesting.
- Human-created memes scored higher on humor and relatability, especially on niche and emotionally nuanced content.
- AI memes, surprisingly, scored better on originality, often due to unexpected punchlines or surreal humor.
- Overall, 38% of participants rated AI memes as funnier than the human ones—proving machines can indeed tickle our funny bones, at least some of the time.
Key Stats at a Glance:
Category | AI Memes Avg. Score | Human Memes Avg. Score |
Humor | 6.8 / 10 | 8.2 / 10 |
Relatability | 6.1 / 10 | 8.5 / 10 |
Originality | 8.4 / 10 | 7.1 / 10 |
Shareability | 7.0 / 10 | 8.0 / 10 |
Why AI Memes Work (And Sometimes Fail)
AI-generated memes often benefit from endless data scraping. Tools like DALL·E, ChatGPT, and MemeCam use vast amounts of online content to build their humor engines. This means they’re fast, quirky, and occasionally brilliant—but not always emotionally accurate.
Where AI Shines:
- Speed & Scale: AI can generate 100 memes in the time it takes a human to draft one.
- Trend Analysis: It can quickly identify what’s viral and format jokes accordingly.
- Unexpected Twists: Some AI punchlines are so bizarre they border on genius (or absurdist comedy).
Where AI Struggles:
- Context: AI doesn’t live life, so sometimes its jokes miss the mark.
- Nuance: Subtle sarcasm or layered humor often goes over AI’s virtual head.
- Cultural Sensitivity: Without human oversight, AI risks being offensive or tone-deaf.
Human Humor Still Has the Edge
Humans bring life experience, pain, love, cultural nuance, and inside jokes that machines can’t yet grasp. A millennial making a meme about growing up with dial-up internet is drawing from lived experience—something no algorithm can replicate authentically.
Why Humans Win:
- Relatability: You’ve been there. AI hasn’t.
- Cultural Knowledge: Memes often require insider knowledge that only humans truly understand.
- Emotion: Whether it’s dark humor or wholesome laughs, emotions still need a human touch.
Actionable Insights for Meme Creators
Whether you’re a marketer, content creator, or just someone who loves to laugh, here’s what our test suggests if you’re thinking of jumping into the meme game.
1. Blend AI and Human Creativity
Use AI tools to brainstorm ideas or generate drafts, but refine with your own flavor. Treat AI as a creative intern, not the final voice.
2. Stay Current, But Add Your Story
Trend-based memes get attention, but personal touches (your reaction, your take, your twist) drive relatability.
3. Test Before Posting
What’s funny to you might not land for others. Show memes to friends or run mini-polls before going viral.
4. Use Free Meme Generators
If you’re just starting out, use platforms that let you create your own meme in minutes—then test which performs better: AI or your own wit.
Final Verdict: AI’s Got Potential, But We’re Not Laughing It Out of a Job (Yet)
AI can create some seriously funny content. It’s fast, weirdly original, and occasionally strikes gold. But the best memes still come from people who’ve lived the joke. That awkward moment when your boss walks in while you’re watching cat videos? AI can simulate it—but you felt it.
In a world where content creation is getting faster and smarter, combining AI’s speed with human storytelling is the meme-making superpower of the future.
So, the next time you’re scrolling through a hilarious post, you might just ask: Did a human make this? Or was it a robot with a better sense of humor than me?